Why a 1% risk plan can cost you 1.3%
A lot size worked out from the stop alone ignores spread and commission. On a tight stop that turns 1% into 1.31%. The arithmetic.
By dynapips research · 6 min read
Because the usual lot size formula only counts the stop. On a $50,000 account, 1% risk and a 5-pip EURUSD stop give 10.00 lots. With a 0.85-pip spread and $7 round-turn commission, that trade loses $655.00 at the stop, or 1.31%. Sizing with the costs included gives 7.63 lots.
How is a 1% lot size usually calculated?
The standard formula divides the money you are prepared to lose by what the stop costs per lot: lot size = risk amount ÷ (stop in pips × pip value per lot). On a $50,000 account, 1% is $500.00. EURUSD is quoted in US dollars, so on a USD account one pip on a standard lot of 100,000 euros is worth exactly $10.00.
With a 5-pip stop, each lot loses $50.00 if the stop is hit, so the formula gives $500.00 ÷ $50.00 = 10.00 lots. Most free calculators, and most traders working it out in their head, stop here.
The formula is right about the stop. It is wrong about the trade, because a trade costs more than its stop distance.
What does the trade actually lose if the stop is hit?
Two costs are missing. You enter at the ask and exit at the bid (or the other way round on a sell), so the spread is lost on every trade, win or lose. And on a raw-spread account you pay commission on the round turn: once to open, once to close.
Add a 0.85-pip spread and $7 per lot round turn to the 10.00 lots from the formula, and the loss at the stop breaks down like this:
| Cost | Per lot | On 10.00 lots |
|---|---|---|
| Stop distance (5 pips) | $50.00 | $500.00 |
| Spread (0.85 pips) | $8.50 | $85.00 |
| Commission (round turn) | $7.00 | $70.00 |
| Total | $65.50 | $655.00 (1.31%) |
You planned to risk $500.00 and the trade risks $655.00. That is 1.31% of the account, not 1%. Nothing went wrong with the trade; the plan never counted what the trade costs.
Why does a tight stop make the gap bigger?
Spread and commission are a fixed cost per lot, while the stop cost grows with distance. The tighter the stop, the bigger the share of the trade the fixed costs take, and the further the pips-only size overshoots.
| Stop | Pips-only size | Real loss at the stop | Size with costs | Costs' share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 pips | 10.00 lots | $655.00 (1.31%) | 7.63 lots | 23.7% |
| 10 pips | 5.00 lots | $577.50 (1.16%) | 4.32 lots | 13.4% |
| 20 pips | 2.50 lots | $538.75 (1.08%) | 2.32 lots | 7.2% |
| 50 pips | 1.00 lots | $515.50 (1.03%) | 0.96 lots | 3% |
On a 50-pip swing stop the costs are 3% of what the trade risks and the error is small. On a 5-pip scalp they are 23.7%. If you trade intraday with tight stops, this is the part of your risk you can't see in a pips-only calculator.
How do you size a trade so 1% really is 1%?
Put the costs in the denominator. Instead of dividing the risk amount by the stop cost alone, divide it by everything one lot costs if the stop is hit:
Lot size = risk amount ÷ (stop pips × pip value + spread pips × pip value + round-turn commission per lot).
On the example: $500.00 ÷ ($50.00 + $8.50 + $7.00) = $500.00 ÷ $65.50, which rounds down to 7.63 lots. At the stop that position loses $499.76: the plan, a few cents under it because platforms trade in steps of 0.01 lots.
The position is 24% smaller than the pips-only answer. That difference is the point: it is the risk the costs were taking without being counted. The lot size calculator does this sum with your spread and commission, so you don't have to work it out before every trade.
How much does the extra cost matter on a prop firm challenge?
Prop firms measure their loss limits against equity, and equity already includes the spread you crossed and the commission you paid. FTMO, for example, defines the equity its daily limit checks as balance plus open profit and loss, plus or minus swaps, minus commissions, and sets the daily limit on its 2-Step Challenge at 5% of the starting balance.
Measured in losses, a 5% daily limit is reached on the fifth loss of exactly 1%. At a real 1.31%, three losses leave 1.07% of room and the fourth breaches the limit. A trader who believes there is room for four losses before the limit has room for three.
On a firm with a 3% daily limit, such as the FundingPips 2 Step option with the lower daily loss, the margin is thinner still. The daily drawdown buffer calculator shows how many losses of your real size are left in the day.
Is a pip always worth $10 a lot?
Only when the pair is quoted in your account currency. A pip on a standard lot is 10 units of the quote currency, so it is $10 on EURUSD, GBPUSD or AUDUSD for a USD account. On other pairs it has to be converted, and the conversion moves with the market:
| Pair | Pip value | How it is worked out |
|---|---|---|
| EURUSD | $10.00 | Exact: quoted in USD |
| USDJPY | $6.67 | Exact at 150 |
| EURGBP | ≈ $12.70 | Converted at rates from 23 October 2026 |
Every dollar of error in the pip value is a dollar of error in every line of the cost table above. If you trade crosses, take the pip value from the platform or your firm's contract specifications at the time of the trade, or use a calculator that converts it from the entry price. The pip value calculator shows the conversion step by step.
What should you check on your own account?
Three inputs decide whether your risk figure is honest. Take each from your account rather than from memory:
- Pip value per lot, from the contract specification of the symbol you trade. On EURUSD it is $10 on a USD account; on a cross such as EURGBP, or on a non-USD account, it changes with the exchange rate.
- Commission per lot, and whether it is quoted per side or for the round turn. If it is per side, double it before you size.
- The spread you are quoted when you place the trade, not the average on the broker's website. It widens at the daily rollover and around news.
If a firm lists commission as a figure per lot, check in its rules or a closed trade's history whether that is charged once or on both sides. FTMO's symbol specifications, for instance, list commission on forex as 5 USD per lot.
Frequently asked questions
- Does the spread count toward a prop firm's daily loss?
- Yes, in effect. A trade opens at a small loss equal to the spread, and the firms' limits are checked against equity, which includes open losses. A trade that is stopped out has lost the stop distance plus the spread.
- Is commission included in the drawdown?
- At most firms, yes. FTMO's definition of equity for its loss limits subtracts commissions and adds or subtracts swaps. Check your firm's rules page for the exact wording.
- Should I just use a wider stop to make the costs smaller?
- A wider stop lowers the costs' share of the trade, but it also means fewer lots, so the money at risk stays the plan either way. Choose the stop from the trade setup, then size from the full cost per lot.
- Do swaps change the lot size?
- Swaps are charged for holding a position overnight, so they don't belong in the sizing of an intraday trade. If you hold for days, the swap adds to the cost and counts toward equity-based limits.