Spread and commission: the real cost of a trade
Every trade pays its spread and commission, win or lose. What that does to your reward-to-risk, the win rate you need and a month of trading.
By dynapips research · 6 min read
A trade costs its spread plus its commission, both paid whether it wins or loses. On EURUSD with a 0.8-pip spread and $7 round-turn commission, one standard lot costs $15.00. On a 10-pip stop that is 13% of what the trade risks, and it turns a 2:1 trade into 1.61:1.
What does a forex trade cost?
Four things, of which two are paid on every trade:
| Cost | When it is paid | On one lot |
|---|---|---|
| Spread | Once per trade: you buy at the ask and sell at the bid | 0.8 pips × $10.00 = $8.00 |
| Commission | On raw-spread accounts, on opening and closing | $7.00 |
| Swap | For each night the position is held | Varies by pair and direction |
| Slippage | When an order fills at a worse price than requested | Varies, mostly on stops and around news |
Spread and commission are certain, so they belong in every trade's plan. Swap matters for trades held overnight; slippage can't be planned exactly but is a reason to leave a margin below any loss limit.
On a prop firm account all of them count against the loss limits. FTMO, for example, measures its limits against equity that includes open profit and loss, swaps and commissions.
How is commission quoted, and how do you compare quotes?
Brokers and firms quote commission in different units. Convert them all to the same one, a round turn per standard lot, before comparing or sizing:
| Quoted as | Round turn per standard lot |
|---|---|
| $3.50 per side, per lot | $7.00 |
| $7.00 per lot, round turn | $7.00 |
| $0.70 per 10,000 units, round turn | $7.00 |
The forex commission calculator turns any of these quotes into a round-turn cost per lot.
Prop firms publish their own. FTMO's symbol specifications list commission on forex as 5 USD per lot, on gold as 0.0014% of the trade's volume, and none on its index CFDs. FundingPips lists, for its 2 Step Master accounts, $5 per lot on forex and metals on standard accounts, $10 on swing and swap-free accounts, and no commission on indices and energies. Where a figure says only "per lot", check a closed trade's history to see whether it was charged once or on each side.
A percentage commission scales with the price. At an example gold price of $4,000 an ounce, one lot of 100 ounces is $400,000 of volume, and 0.0014% of that is $5.60.
How much of your risk do the costs take?
Costs are fixed per lot while the stop's cost grows with its distance, so the tighter the stop, the larger the share the costs take. At $15.00 of costs per lot, a 10-pip stop risks $100.00 of stop and $15.00 of costs per lot: the costs are 13% of the trade's real risk.
If the lot size was worked out from the stop alone, that share is risk you are carrying without having planned it. Why a 1% plan can cost 1.3% works through what it does to a 1% plan and to a daily loss limit.
How do costs change your reward-to-risk and the win rate you need?
Costs come off the winners and add to the losers. A trade planned at 2:1, with a target twice the stop, wins less than 2R and loses more than 1R once they are paid. Without costs it breaks even at a 33.3% win rate. With them:
| Stop | Costs' share of the risk | Reward-to-risk after costs | Break-even win rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 pips | 23.1% | 1.31R | 43.3% |
| 10 pips | 13% | 1.61R | 38.3% |
| 20 pips | 7% | 1.79R | 35.8% |
| 50 pips | 2.9% | 1.91R | 34.3% |
On a 10-pip stop the trade that looked like 2:1 is 1.61:1, and the win rate it needs to break even rises from 33.3% to 38.3%. A strategy tested on charts without costs can show a profit that the same strategy, traded, doesn't make.
The risk-reward calculator shows the break-even win rate for any reward-to-risk.
How much do costs add up to over a month?
Take a $100,000 account risking 1% on 10-pip EURUSD stops, sized with the costs included: 8.69 lots a trade, paying $130.35 of spread and commission on every one. At 60 trades a month, about three a trading day, that is $7,821 a month.
That is 7.8% of the account, paid before any trade's result, on an evaluation whose target might be 10%. Costs are not a reason to avoid trading, but they are the reason the same strategy needs a larger edge on short stops than on long ones, and the reason trade frequency is part of a plan, not only a habit.
How can you lower what each trade costs?
Some of it is in your control:
- Size the trade from the spread you are quoted when you place it. Spreads widen around the daily rollover and major news releases, and the cost of a trade is the spread at that moment, not the average.
- Compare commission on a round-turn basis per lot, using the same units for every provider.
- Look at the costs' share, not only the costs. Wider stops with smaller lots pay less in costs for the same money at risk, because the costs are charged per lot.
- Check which instruments carry commission at all. FTMO lists none on its index CFDs, and FundingPips none on indices on its Master accounts, so the spread is the whole cost there.
How do you put the costs into your lot size?
Divide the money you are risking by everything one lot costs if the stop is hit: lot size = risk ÷ (stop pips × pip value + spread pips × pip value + round-turn commission per lot). Round down to the platform's lot step.
For the month above: $1,000.00 ÷ ($100.00 + $8.00 + $7.00) = 8.69 lots. The lot size calculator takes the spread and the commission in whichever unit your provider quotes it and does this for every trade.
Frequently asked questions
- Is the spread paid twice, on entry and exit?
- No, once per trade. You buy at the ask and sell at the bid, so a round trip crosses the spread once. A trade opens showing a loss equal to the spread for that reason.
- Is commission charged on losing trades?
- Yes. Commission is charged on the volume traded, on opening and closing, whatever the result. That is why it belongs in the loss at the stop.
- Do prop firms charge commission on challenge accounts?
- Check your firm's own figures. FTMO publishes a commission for each symbol, and FundingPips publishes its commission table for the Master account by instrument and account type. Either way, firms that measure their limits against equity count the commission you pay.
- What is a raw-spread account?
- An account that quotes the market's spread with little or no markup and charges a separate commission per lot. A standard account puts its charge into a wider spread instead. Compare the two by the total cost per lot.